Controversies

Gabrielle Union Files Discrimination Complaint Against America’s Got Talent

Union’s complaint, filed Thursday, cites Universal Television, as well as show creator and judge Simon Cowell.
Image may contain Human Person Julianne Hough Coat Clothing Overcoat Apparel Suit Simon Cowell and Fashion
Photo by Trae Patton/NBC.

Former America’s Got Talent judge Gabrielle Union filed a discrimination complaint on Thursday against judge and creator Simon Cowell, production companies Fremantle Productions North America and Syco Entertainment, and Universal Television. The action comes more than six months after Union left the popular talent competition series following a one-season stint as judge, amid claims the work environment there was “toxic.”

“Union, an African American woman, was a judge on America’s Got Talent, but, in what has become a widely publicized matter, was terminated from the Cowell-created show after just one season,” reads the opening of the claim. “Sadly, what led to Union’s termination was her refusal to remain silent in the face of a toxic culture at AGT that included racist jokes, racist performances, sexual orientation discrimination, and excessive focus on female judges’ appearances, including race-related comments.”

The legal filing goes on to cite numerous alleged incidents that have been previously reported, including that Cowell smoked indoors despite a California law that bans smoking in the workplace—which Union previously told Variety left her “sick for two months straight.”

Also cited are what Union described as racist comments made by judge Howie Mandel and guest judge Jay Leno. Per the claim: “Mandell [sic] mocked a Spanish-singing performer from Arizona by stating that, in sum and substance, America would not be able to ‘understand’ her singing. Union complained about Mandell’s [sic] racist comment to NBC’s Vice President of Talent Relations and shared her concern that Mandell’s comments essentially conveyed a message to 41 million United States Spanish-speaking residents that unless you speak English you cannot be successful on the show and that there is no room for contestants that do not speak or perform in English.”

Of Leno, the claim adds, “During a now-infamous segment that Jay Leno filmed in the presence of Union and the AGT Judges, Leno made a joke about a painting of Cowell surrounded by his dogs, stating that Cowell’s dogs ‘looked like something one would find on the menu at a Korean restaurant.’ Union complained to the producers on AGT that Leno’s joke was racist and urged them to report Leno’s joke to human resources at NBC.”

Previously, neither Mandel nor Leno had commented on Union’s allegations. In a statement to Variety last month, a representative for Cowell said that when the judge “was directly informed of the smoking complaint during the first couple of days of the season, he immediately changed his behavior and the issue was never raised again.” A representative for Cowell and his company, Syco, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Thursday.

The claim also alleges Union was criticized for her hair being “too wild,” an “unsolicited opinion” that was not production-based and later interpreted to mean Union’s hair was “too black.”

In the wake of Union’s ouster, NBC, Fremantle, and Syco announced an investigation into the show’s workplace environment. Last month, in a statement, the companies revealed the investigation’s conclusions: “Through the investigation process, it has been revealed that no one associated with the show made any insensitive or derogatory remarks about Ms. Union’s appearance, and that neither race nor gender was a contributing factor in the advancement or elimination of contestants at any time. The investigation has shown that the concerns raised by Ms. Union had no bearing on the decision not to exercise the option on her contract.”

But the discrimination claim filed Thursday alleges that NBC made changes to the findings of the investigation before presenting it to Union on March 4. “At the outset of this meeting, the investigator revealed that she had previously disclosed the preliminary result of her ‘investigation’ to NBC several weeks earlier outside of the presence of Union. The investigator, who was hired by NBC and Fremantle, acknowledged, among other things, that she had already made changes to her preliminary findings at the direction of NBC and Fremantle. The investigator also cautioned that her findings should not be construed to suggest that a proper ‘investigation’ was performed.”

“When Gabrielle Union informed NBC of racially offensive conduct during the taping of America’s Got Talent, NBC did not ‘stand’ with her in ‘outrage at acts of racism,’” attorney Bryan Freedman said in a statement first posted by journalist Yashar Ali on Twitter. Freedman’s comments reference a recent tweet in support of the Black Lives Matter movement from NBC.

X content

This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from.

He continued, “Instead, NBC did not care enough to either promptly investigate Ms. Union’s complaints or even ask HR to get involved. Rather, NBC stood against her and directed its ‘outrage’ at Ms. Union for whistleblowing about the racially offensive conduct she experienced while working for NBC on America’s Got Talent. In sharp contrast to NBC’s recent statement on race, what was truly an ‘outrage’ was the fact that Paul Telegdy, Chairman of NBC Entertainment, actually threatened Ms. Union in an attempt to silence her from telling the truth about racist actions that took place on the show. There is no place for this type of racial bullying in the workplace, and it is going to take more than a Tweet from NBC to demonstrate that NBC intends to create an environment free from racism.”

About that: In the claim, Union’s lawyers allege that earlier this year, “Telegdy threatened Union through her agent and warned Union’s agent that Union had better cease from pursuing her claims of racism while filming AGT. Union’s agent was shocked that the Chairman of NBC Entertainment was attempting to threaten and intimidate Union. Union’s agent could not recall another instance in his career when a senior executive at a network had threatened and intimidated an employee during an ongoing workplace investigation.”

In response, a representative for NBC told Deadline, “The allegation that anyone involved in this process threatened Ms. Union is categorically untrue. We took Ms. Union‘s concerns seriously and engaged an outside investigator who found an overarching culture of diversity on the show. NBCUniversal remains committed to creating an inclusive and supportive working environment where people of all backgrounds are treated with respect.”

More Great Stories From Vanity Fair

“Can We Live?” The Daughter of Civil Rights Activists on the Question That’s Haunted Her for Decades
Catherine O’Hara, Queen of Schitt’s Creek, Talks Gilda Radner Friendship & More
— Exclusive: Stephen King’s The Stand Comes to Life Again
— Jeffrey Epstein: Seven Remaining Mysteries—And Disturbing Revelations
— Old Hollywood’s Most Scandalous Secrets, as Told by David Niven
— Trevor Noah and The Daily Show Aren’t Just Surviving—They’re Thriving
— From the Archive: Sidney Poitier’s Pointed Message to White America as Race Riots Swept the Nation in the Summer of 1967

Looking for more? Sign up for our daily Hollywood newsletter and never miss a story.