Immigration

Stephen Miller Planned Mass Arrests of Immigrant Parents and Kids

Kirstjen Nielsen and other top officials blocked the plan, which would have targeted thousands for deportation. Now, those officials are gone.
Image may contain Hat Clothing Apparel Tie Accessories Accessory Coat Suit Overcoat Human Person and Room
Stephen Miller looks on as Donald Trump speaks during a roundtable on border security in January.Alex Wong/Getty Images

The ouster of former Department of Homeland Security head Kirstjen Nielsen, who was reportedly considered a “soft-on-the-border Bushy” by Donald Trump’s more hardline advisers, was essentially a power grab by Stephen Miller, who now has free rein to shape the department in his image. And on Tuesday, The Washington Post gave us an idea of what the future of D.H.S. might look like under Miller’s hand. Per the Post, Miller championed a plan to arrest thousands of immigrant parents and their children in cities across the country—a “blitz” operation meant to send a message that the administration is serious about its immigration crackdown.

The operation reportedly aimed to target as many as 10,000 immigrants in 10 cities, including New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago. It was an attractive option for Miller and Trump, who has pushed to adopt the “toughest” policies possible on immigration. But Nielsen and former Immigration and Customs Enforcement Acting Director Ronald Vitiello pushed back, not due to moral qualms, but because in true Trumpian fashion, the plan was so poorly thought out. “The proposal was nowhere near ready for prime time,” a D.H.S. official told the Post. Nielsen and Vitiello, who had his nomination for permanent I.C.E. director abruptly withdrawn, raised concerns about a lack of preparation, the potential for blowback, and the siphoning of resources from the border. “Both [Vitiello] and Nielsen instinctively thought it was bad policy and that the proposal was less than half-baked,” another DHS official told the Post. Their unwillingness to execute the ill-conceived sweep was reportedly a factor in the president’s decision to axe them. (Officials at ICE and DHS declined to comment to the Post, as did Miller, while Vitiello and Nielsen did not respond to the Post’s request for comment.)

Trump unceremoniously dispatched the duo in April, telling reporters he withdrew Vitiello’s nomination to go in a “tougher” direction, and forcing Nielsen to resign days later, apparently angry that her depravity had its limits where his clearly did not. (Separating children from their parents was apparently an insufficient show of strength.) With Nielsen and Vitiello gone, the president and his most ghoulish immigration hawks seem poised to get even more aggressive. They’re said to be plotting efforts to ramp up deportations, apply more scrutiny to which immigrants and asylum-seekers the country admits, and, yes, re-start family separations.

Whether the purges will still take effect is unclear. The plan seems to be missing key details; as the Post reported, Nielsen and Vitiello’s concerns included how Trump’s immigration authorities would handle undocumented parents with children who are U.S. citizens, the possibility that kids could be separated from their families during the raids, and a lack of beds for families in detention. But that it’s ill-conceived is almost the point. The administration’s other high-profile crackdowns—the Muslim ban of 2017, the zero-tolerance policy of 2018, and the big dumb wall Trump is still pushing for—have been similarly chaotic. In pursuing these and similar plans regardless, Trump and his goons are signaling that they just don’t care. “The level of depravity in terms of this administration has no bounds,” Melissa Mark-Viverito, president of the Latino Victory Project and a former New York City Council speaker, told the Post. “There is no sense of the understanding what the implications are for the greater society. There is no consideration that these families are making positive economic contributions to these cities. It is about fear-mongering to the nth degree.”

More Great Stories from Vanity Fair

— Inside the Zuckerberg–Winklevoss conference-room showdown

— How Michael Cohen spent his final days before prison

— Was this former Trump adviser scamming elderly MAGA voters?

— How Bono’s investment partner got busted in the college-admissions scandal

— If impeaching Trump is too tricky, is Barr a softer target for the Democrats?

Looking for more? Sign up for our daily Hive newsletter and never miss a story.