2020 Election

Biden’s Lead Over Trump Looks Massive—But Is He as Strong as He Seems With Independents?

Transactional, late-deciding, and focused on the economy, independents could still swing Trump’s way under the right circumstances.
Image may contain Suit Coat Clothing Overcoat Apparel Flag Symbol Human Crowd Person Tie and Accessories
By Matt Slocum/AP/Shutterstock.

At this point, even Donald Trump knows he’s losing. Those around him have reportedly come to realize that his disastrous polling could make him a one-term president. Much of that polling shift has occurred in the last three weeks, reflecting a “performance evaluation,” as UCLA political scientist Lynn Vavreck put it to me, on Trump’s handling of COVID-19, the Black Lives Matter movement, and the shaky economy. And according to a new analysis of polling data and interviews with voters in key states, much of it has come at the hands of independent voters. The movement is significant—enough to make the Washington Post opinion section gush that Trump looks “down and out” and Democrats are “heavy favorites.” Yet the very nature of independent voters, many of whom pay little attention until the eve of the election, makes it unwise to put much stock in the idea that 2020 is Biden’s to lose.

In 2016, Trump was elected in part because enough independent voters were willing to take a flier on a candidate who promised to undermine a political order that had not served them well. Trump’s advantage among independents, while only four points, was enough to carry him to victory. Independents comprise the largest segment of the voting-age population: 40% according to a June Gallup poll. Some self-identified independents are closet partisans, but many are true swing voters, or low-information voters without much ideological loyalty. It is these less-loyal voters who have moved away from Trump in large numbers. In the latest Morning Consult tracking poll, independents favored Biden by 8.5 points.

The reasons for this are not particularly mysterious. Over the last three months, Trump’s favorability ratings among independents have tanked across key measures such as the handling of the coronavirus pandemic, his response to the protests over George Floyd’s death at the hands of police, and even his management of the economy. More than his Twitter outrages or race baiting, it’s his lack of effectiveness that’s turning off some independents. Rick Mirabito, a county commissioner in Lycoming County in central Pennsylvania, told me that the “euphoria of people who thought he would get things done has passed.” Todd Franko, a former top editor at the now shuttered Youngstown Vindicator, reported similar reactions not to the fantasy of Trump but to the reality of him: “people haven’t given up on the idea of experimenting, but this one didn’t work.” For the better part of three years, independents have stuck with Trump, willing to take “commerce over conscious,” as Franko put it to me. That deal has made a certain amount of sense to many independents, who tend to be more transactional and less ideological when it comes to politics, but it has looked increasingly less fruitful in recent months. Given the shaky nature of the Trump coalition, if he can’t reclaim ground with independents, it’s hard to see a path to victory for him.

Yet it is far too early to call it for Biden. There’s the normal caution: four months to go in an extraordinarily volatile year. But more importantly, independents are a difficult breed to predict. Many are independents because they care little about politics and may not decide their vote until November. As David Brady, a political scientist at Stanford, noted to me, it is an ironic aspect of American politics that our elections are often decided by the voters with the least interest in the candidates and the least knowledge of the issues. Given the ubiquity of Trump’s coverage and the familiarity of a challenger first elected to the Senate almost a half century ago, it would seem that it would be difficult to find a voter without a settled view. And yet a full 30% of independents reported to Morning Consult that they were undecided. Late deciders broke heavily for Trump in 2016, including those in Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Florida who decided in the week before the election. The existence of a mass of undecideds this time around is likely to confound any bold prediction of an early Biden knockout.

The state of the economy is another wild card among independents. Typically, a bad economy in the first half of the year would be a devastating blow for the incumbent. In this unusual year, however, Trump still retains an edge (if a declining one) with independents on the economy—a critical advantage for a group that often views politics in transactional terms. To the extent that the economy rebounds in the fall, Trump may be able to convince independents he’s a safer bet to keep things moving. Roger Ford, a local business leader and political observer in Pikeville, Kentucky, told me that swing voters in the eastern part of the state are sticking with Trump so far because of their faith in his stewardship of the economy and because they see the election through a “nationalist versus globalist” economic lens. For those voters, Trump’s recent invocation of the coronavirus as the “kung flu” is a reminder of the dangers of globalization and that he, not Biden, is the bulwark against China and other outside threats.

To some observers, the race is perceived as an up-or-down referendum on Trump, which is convenient for Biden. Despite his reputation as a likable centrist, he doesn’t test particularly well with independents. In the Morning Consult tracking survey, Biden rated at minus 15 (35% approval, 50% disapproval), and even in polls where he has scored better, his support is soft. In the most recent New York Times/Siena College Poll, two thirds of the independents who were favorable to Biden were only “somewhat favorable.” Like others, Dave Betras, a Democratic Party leader in Youngstown, Ohio, has started to see tentative signs of changing attitudes among the Trump–Obama voters who defined the last election. But Biden will need to give them a reason to vote for him. “No sane human being would commit to a stranger,” he told me.

So far, Biden has been happy to sit back and watch Trump beat himself. But it seems unlikely that this strategy will endear him to independents for another four months. As Biden emerges from his basement, and as voters begin to pay attention to a wave of vicious attacks from the right, the question of whether his soft support among independents can hold will be a crucial one.

More Great Stories From Vanity Fair

— The Parallel Universe of Ivanka Trump, America’s Dissociated Princess
“No, I Am Not Okay”: A Black Journalist Addresses His White Friends
— Why Bankrupt Hertz Is a Pandemic Zombie
— Scenes of Fury and Mourning at the Minneapolis Protests
Civil Rights Advocate Brandi Collins-Dexter on Why Facebook Chooses Trump Over Democracy
— Democrats’ Blue-Texas Fever Dream May Finally Become a Reality
— From the Archive: Taking Stock of Melania Trump, the Unprepared—And Lonely—FLOTUS

Looking for more? Sign up for our daily Hive newsletter and never miss a story.